Key failings included decisions to discharge thousands of untested hospital patients into care homes and imposition of blanket DNARs
Care home managers and staff say they were left without guidance, PPE or access to testing
Amnesty calls for a full independent public inquiry to commence immediately, and for the revision of current restrictive visiting guidelines
A series of “shockingly irresponsible” Government decisions put tens of thousands of older people’s lives at risk and led to multiple violations of care home residents’ human rights, said Amnesty International today, following an investigation by the human rights group’s Crisis Response team.Amnesty’s 50-page report - As If Expendable: The UK Government’s Failure to Protect Older People in Care Homes during the COVID-19 Pandemic- shows that care home residents were effectively abandoned in the early stages of the pandemic.Between 2 March and 12 June this year 28,186 “excess deaths” were recorded in care homes in England, with over 18,500 care home residents confirmed to have died with COVID-19 during this period.Care home managers and staff described to Amnesty “a complete breakdown” of systems in the first six weeks of the pandemic response. They spoke of waiting to receive guidance, struggling to access (adequate amounts of) PPE, and of having no access to testing, despite having to manage infected patients urgently discharged from hospitals.Most shockingly, on 17 March, four days after the World Health Organization (WHO) declared COVID-19 a global pandemic, the Government ordered the discharge of 25,000 patients from hospitals into care homes, including those infected or possibly infected with COVID-19.On 2 April, the same day that the WHO confirmed the existence of pre-symptomatic cases of COVID-19, the Government reiterated its guidance for hospital discharge that ‘Negative tests are not required prior to transfers/admissions into the care home’.Several care home managers told Amnesty that they had no COVID-19 in their homes until after they received patients discharged from the hospital. The manager of a care home in Yorkshire said:“Because of what we’d witnessed in Spain and Italy, we stopped visitors on 28 February and got PPE. We had no cases until 28 March when a resident was discharged from hospital with COVID.”These and other decisions are taken by the Government led to violations of human rights of older people in care homes during the pandemic - notably their right to life, their right to health, and their right to non-discrimination.
The Government made a series of shockingly irresponsible decisions which abandoned care home residents to die. ... The appalling death toll was entirely avoidable - it is a scandal of monumental proportions. Kate Allen, Director of Amnesty International UK
Kate Allen, Director of Amnesty International UK, said:“The Government made a series of shockingly irresponsible decisions which abandoned care home residents to die.“Discharged without being tested, thousands of older people were sent to care homes at great risk to themselves and other residents and to staff.“The appalling death toll was entirely avoidable - it is a scandal of monumental proportions.“As the country faces a second wave of coronavirus, we urgently need a full independent public inquiry into the care home scandal, so that lessons can be learned and lives protected, before any more lives are lost.”Amnesty International UK has launched a new campaign calling for a full independent public Inquiry into the pandemic, with an interim phase starting immediately focusing on older people in care homes.The human rights organization is calling on the Government to also:
Order a thorough review of Do Not Attempt Resuscitation (DNAR) forms in care home residents’ care plans and medical files to ensure they were not imposed without due process;
Ensure that care home residents have full access to the NHS services to which they are entitled.
Make regular testing available to care home visitors, as well as to care home residents and staff
Ensure that guidelines for care home visits put the best interests of the residents at the center and that restriction is based on individual risk assessments, taking into account all possible risk-mitigating measures – such as more frequent testing for care workers, residents, and visitors.